Zelenskyy questions US understanding of NATO-style security guarantees
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy (photo: facebook.com_zelenskyy.official)
Ukraine lacks a clear understanding of how security guarantees modeled on NATO's Article 5 would work. This includes the possible presence of foreign troops on Ukrainian territory and how allies would respond to renewed Russian aggression, President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said during a meeting with the media.
He noted that the US, together with its European partners, is ready to offer Ukraine security guarantees modeled on NATO's Article 5. However, the parties do not yet share a common understanding of what exactly these guarantees would mean in practice.
"I'm not sure that we have a common understanding of Article 5," Zelenskyy said.
The president explained that, for him, one element of security guarantees is the presence of military forces from partner countries in Ukraine. In particular, he raised the possibility of deploying US troops and military bases.
"I'm not supportive or not supportive. Of course, we would be happy if our American partners trusted their troops, if their bases were in Ukraine, like in the Middle East. By the way, they are not in NATO, but there are some bases," the president noted.
He added that he still has no answer as to whether the guarantees would include the presence of American and European troops.
"This is, for me, part of Article 5: forces, United States and European partners, forces, bases. Without this, I'm not sure that it's Article 4, 5, and so on," Zelenskyy explained.
How allies should respond to renewed aggression
At the same time, he said the main question concerns the specific actions allies would take in the event of another Russian attack. According to him, Ukraine needs to understand in advance exactly how its partners would respond to aggression.
"Not if — forgive my skepticism — but when they try to do it again, what will they do?" the president asked.
The president emphasized that clear answers are needed not only by the governments of partner countries but also by society, citizens, and potential investors. Reliable security guarantees must be understandable to businesses that may enter Ukraine, as well as to people considering returning.
"Everybody wants to invest in Ukraine. [...] People are strong; they showed it. Nine million people — we hope that they will come back. And for all these people, what do they need? They need clear answers," Zelenskyy said.
He also stressed that Ukraine needs an explanation of how guarantees modeled on Article 5 would work without NATO membership.
"Okay, great, Article 5, no NATO. Okay, explain to us what it means," the president noted.
US special envoy Jared Kushner said today that Russia had agreed to the concept of security guarantees for Ukraine similar to NATO's Article 5.
He said that American negotiators had made significant progress in discussions on security guarantees. Kushner believes that Russia already accepts this model.