Dorothy Shea becomes unexpected face of Trump’s 'America First' foreign policy

Dorothy Shea, the top-ranking US representative at the United Nations, once described Russia’s invasion of Ukraine as "unprovoked" and "unjustified."

But this February, she delivered a stunning policy reversal by opposing a UN resolution condemning Moscow’s actions, as the Trump administration opened ceasefire talks with Russia.

"Let us show one another that the bold vision of peace that once pulled us out of hell can prevail," Shea urged in a speech that signaled a new diplomatic tone from Washington.

Her message downplayed Moscow’s aggression and instead called for consensus and restraint, marking a significant break from the US stance under previous administrations.

Dorothy Camille Shea, experienced US diplomat (Photo: Getty Images)

Shea’s vote against the European-backed resolution stunned allies and emphasized America’s shift away from traditional transatlantic unity.

"This was an inflection point," noted Phillip Reeker, former acting assistant secretary of state for Europe. "Not just a change of administration, but the end of a whole era of US foreign policy."

From Lebanon to the UN: Diplomat’s evolving role

With more than 30 years in the Foreign Service, Shea has served presidents from both parties.

She previously held positions in South Africa, Israel, and Lebanon — where her criticism of Hezbollah once led to a media ban.

In 2023, former President Biden appointed her as the deputy ambassador to the UN. Now, she leads the mission as Trump’s final pick for the role, Congresswoman Elise Stefanik, was withdrawn from Senate consideration.

While her current position remains interim, Shea continues to represent the United States during a critical reshaping of its international stance.

The Trump administration has proposed sweeping cuts to UN funding and other global programs, reflecting a deeper push toward isolationism. The State Department and US Mission to the UN declined to comment on Shea’s future or the direction of upcoming nominations.

Shea’s continued presence underscores Trump’s decision last month to keep Elise Stefanik in Congress rather than confirm her as ambassador — a move driven by the need to preserve the GOP’s slim majority in the House. As Trump put it, "there are others that can do a good job at the United Nations."